Note first off:
S P O I L E R S ! It's not possible to discuss the points that interest me without them. So if you haven't seen the movie yet, be aware. (To skip over this post without having to scroll through it,
click here.) Some of this won't make sense unless you've seen it, anyway.
This isn't really a comprehensive review; I want to focus on a few themes that especially interested me. I do strongly recommend it, though. If you liked the original for its visual beauty and spectacle, you'll
love this. The characters have all developed substantially since the first film, while remaining true to themselves. There's plenty of humor, largely from Olaf, the naïve snowman turned storyteller and amateur philosopher. As to the songs, there's no second "Let It Go", but several of them are excellent.
On the whole I'd say it's as good as the original. It seems on track to be at least equally popular (
$739 million in 12 days). The showing I went to was at 10:30 AM and there were well over 100 people there, mostly families with small kids, and there was widespread applause at the end. As I've
discussed before, pop culture is important because it reaches millions of people who ignore or actively avoid politics and political media; its messages influence those whom conventional discourse cannot.
The storyline concerns a mysterious threat to Arendelle. To learn about this menace and defeat it, Elsa, Anna, Kristoff, Olaf, and Sven travel to a remote forest which has been cut off from the world for decades. There they find the Northuldra -- the forest's indigenous people -- plus a group of Arendellian soldiers who have long been trapped there. After much struggle, conflict, disturbing revelations about the past, and encounters with supernatural monsters, they come to understand the threat and what to do about it. The points I find particularly interesting are:
The villain. There isn't one. This is unusual because drama requires conflict, and the easiest way of generating conflict is to have an active antagonist trying to thwart the heroes. Even the first movie had Hans, whose slimy machinations drove a lot of the story. Here, the main obstacle the heroes face is ignorance -- they don't know the underlying reason for the threat to their country, and need to discover the truth in order to save the day.
This doesn't fit the usual pattern of storytelling, but it does reflect how problems and solutions most often work in the real world. Eliminating smallpox wasn't a matter of defeating an evil villain any more than getting rid of that suspicious noise from your car engine is. Such problems are solved by understanding what's causing them so you can devise an appropriate countermeasure.
As in real life, the ultimate horror is death itself, an impersonal force. And as in the first movie, even death wins only temporarily, with life being restored by the power of doing the right thing.
Human mastery of nature. A recurring theme that appeals to me is how human intelligence and determination achieve dominance over "spirits" (and the natural forces they embody), however frightening and powerful the latter appear at first.
In the most obvious example, late in the movie, Elsa tries to reach Ahtohallan by
running across a stormy ocean, which despite her powers does not go well. She is attacked by the Nokk, a water spirit in the form of a horse. She fights back and manages to mount the Nokk, staying on despite its efforts to throw her, until it is "broken" like a real horse. For the rest of the film the Nokk is her obedient servant, which she rides wherever she wishes to go.
After entering the forest, Elsa's party is bedeviled by the mischievous wind spirit "Gale" which eventually sweeps them all up into a tornado. After overcoming initial panic, Elsa freezes the tornado, ending the danger to herself and her friends. By the end of movie, Gale has been tamed and is helpfully carrying written messages back and forth between the two sisters in their separate realms.
Soon after meeting the Northuldra, our heroes are attacked by a
terrifying, sentient outbreak of fire which leaps from tree to tree,
scatters all humans in the vicinity, and threatens to incinerate the
Northuldra village. Rather than flee in terror, Elsa fights back with
blasts of ice, beating down the flames (especially when they threaten
Anna), saving the village, and eventually reducing the fire to a tiny
pocket of combustion which then reveals its true form as a small
salamander-like creature which befriends her and never again threatens
humans.
Finally, the immense rock giants appear terrifying, but in the end they are easily manipulated by Anna into using their vast strength to serve the purpose she sets for them.
The lesbianism thing. In the first movie, the epic song "Let It Go" was widely interpreted as a coded paean to gay self-discovery and liberation, while Elsa's lack of any romantic interest in males (in marked contrast to Anna) left the door open to reading the character as lesbian, with the repression and fear directed at her ice powers paralleling society's reactions to homosexuality. Much of the blogosphere hoped that the sequel would make this explicit, with a "hashtag"
#GiveElsaAGirlfriend in support. The movement attracted enough attention to trigger religious prigs to
start a petition against it. So Disney was certainly aware of the campaign and knew that at least some of the audience would be looking for clues along these lines.
First off, no,
Frozen 2 does not explicitly or even implicitly make Elsa a lesbian. But it does include certain details which the writers must have known would be read that way by those who were interested in doing so, while flying under the radar of viewers who weren't.
In the forest, Elsa meets a young Northuldra woman named Honeymaren. Their on-screen interactions are limited to two brief episodes. In the first, Honeymaren explains the symbols on a shawl Elsa is wearing; it's a "getting to know each other" moment. In the second, after the film's main action is over, Honeymaren tells Elsa "you belong here" -- in the forest, not back home in Arendelle where she is queen. These scenes suggest friendship, while not ruling out something closer for those who want to see it. There's no other apparent reason for this character to even exist in the story.
But Elsa
does then stay in the forest, abdicating as queen of Arendelle in favor of Anna, leaving not only her home country but the sister to whom she's been so devoted for most of two movies. The script offers no logical reason why Elsa would do this. It's not that her powers make her too dangerous. Unlike in the first movie, when she ended up staying in Arendelle after almost destroying it, she's now just
saved the kingdom from destruction by flood. It's not that she's tired of the hard work of being queen, or at least, the early part of the film gives no hint of such feelings. Yet it would take something fairly weighty to get her to leave her home and her sister permanently. The script never explicitly suggests that it's to be near Honeymaren, but there's no other obvious explanation.
Some might be disappointed that the film is not more upfront, but this misreads the way movies work and the environment in which they deliver their message. An explicit lesbian theme might well have gotten the movie banned in major markets like China and Russia (as it is, there was
a bit of editing in some places), and would have triggered a storm of controversy from religious crazies in the US, barring it from millions of potential viewers and overshadowing its main mission of light entertainment. Movies that throw a blatant message in the audience's face are usually clunky and arouse resistance, as the godawful "Christian movie" industry shows. The first
Frozen's subtle approach with Elsa's powers and "Let It Go" flew under the censors' radar and reached hundreds of millions of people in ways that an explicitly "gay" film could never have done.
In any case, fans seem to be falling for Honeymaren's briefly-displayed charms, with
fanfic and
fanart already appearing, and even
a riff on a classic joke. As for the now-inevitable third movie, you can
take this for whatever you think it's worth.
