30 September 2015
29 September 2015
Odds and ends
NASA confirms that there is flowing liquid water on Mars, at least during the summer. This seems strange given that the temperature is still below freezing, but the water is probably salty, which can lower the melting point. This doesn't mean there's life on Mars, much less intelligent life -- but it has again confirmed the existence of stupid life on Earth.
By 60% to 32%, Americans believe that any budget deal must fully fund Planned Parenthood, and if there is a government shutdown, 40% will blame Republicans while only 26% will blame Democrats. This was never a winning issue for the wingnuts -- most media reports I've seen on the videos that started this latest kerfluffle have mentioned the fact that they were deceptively edited to give the false impression that Planned Parenthood was selling fetal tissue, so voters outside the right-wing bubble are well aware that this claim is a lie.
Among the Muslim migrants arriving in Germany, substantial numbers are abandoning Islam and converting to Christianity. Likely their true motive is to improve their odds of winning permanent residency, since Islamic law (as actually applied by some Middle Eastern regimes such as ISIS) imposes the death penalty for any Muslim who renounces Islam, and a civilized country won't deport refugees back to where they might face such a fate. But if people will convert from one religion to another out of expediency, they probably don’t have much of a fanatical commitment to either one. Once they’re settled in Germany they’ll easily be swept along in the general trend toward secularism among the general population in Europe which is making religion meaningless, regardless of which religion a person starts out with. They're not the kind of people Europe needs to worry about. What Europe needs to worry about is slimebuckets like this guy who refuse to assimilate. Like the fundies in the US, they are getting fewer but remain dangerous.
By 60% to 32%, Americans believe that any budget deal must fully fund Planned Parenthood, and if there is a government shutdown, 40% will blame Republicans while only 26% will blame Democrats. This was never a winning issue for the wingnuts -- most media reports I've seen on the videos that started this latest kerfluffle have mentioned the fact that they were deceptively edited to give the false impression that Planned Parenthood was selling fetal tissue, so voters outside the right-wing bubble are well aware that this claim is a lie.
Among the Muslim migrants arriving in Germany, substantial numbers are abandoning Islam and converting to Christianity. Likely their true motive is to improve their odds of winning permanent residency, since Islamic law (as actually applied by some Middle Eastern regimes such as ISIS) imposes the death penalty for any Muslim who renounces Islam, and a civilized country won't deport refugees back to where they might face such a fate. But if people will convert from one religion to another out of expediency, they probably don’t have much of a fanatical commitment to either one. Once they’re settled in Germany they’ll easily be swept along in the general trend toward secularism among the general population in Europe which is making religion meaningless, regardless of which religion a person starts out with. They're not the kind of people Europe needs to worry about. What Europe needs to worry about is slimebuckets like this guy who refuse to assimilate. Like the fundies in the US, they are getting fewer but remain dangerous.
28 September 2015
Video of the day -- I am the very model of a modern fundamentalist
Found via Squatlo Rant. Slightly NSFW.
27 September 2015
Link round-up for 27 September 2015
Maybe "insert" wasn't the best word to use here.
Time to put down one of the walking dead.
Reading is good for you.
Meet Guillaume de Gentil, the most frustrated scientist in history.
At least 155 people are really into Mary Tyler Moore (NSFW, found via Mendip).
Lowry pwns Trump on Fox, Trump throws tantrum on Twitter, much mockery ensues. But he's still very much in the lead.
Many people find themselves drawn to this lifestyle, but it has its unhealthy side.
Here are ten beautiful bridges -- I find #10 the most beautiful (though they got the name wrong), #8 the most impressive when you consider how long it's stood since it was built.
Witches' Pond in Virginia is shrouded in myth, but has one genuine mystery death to its credit (found via Mendip).
We are the fastest-growing group in the US.
Supporting an anti-bullying campaign is now "anti-Christian hate and oppression", apparently.
A Catholic shrine in France illustrates what a scam religion is.
Here's a bad person and a good one.
Probably best not to resettle any Syrian refugees in this part of South Carolina. It seems to be full of the same religious hatred and potential for conflict that they're fleeing from.
More and more of ISIS's fighters are abandoning the group.
Fox's January stories about Muslim "no go zones" in Britain may finally have gotten it in legal trouble.
Here's a message from 2013 for the anti-Planned-Parenthood nuts.
Sex workers in South Korea march for decriminalization, encouraged by Amnesty International's support.
Christian songs play a growing role in worship -- and they're terrible. But religion's Orwellian use of words (found via Republic of Gilead) is worse.
A teenager in North Carolina is facing felony sex charges for taking nude pictures of himself.
Secular Ethics blog dissects the weirdly-common "what if everyone was gay" argument.
The government-shutdown push was a con game -- against the wingnut base (found via Zandar).
If you're rich and Christian, read this.
Here's more police abuse, this time from Boston. And an ex-cop looks at the James Blake case.
Stop treating the Pope as a liberal hero. He's still evading the one issue any true reformist Pope must address.
Some Tennessee Republicans don't understand the Supreme Court's Constitutional power (found via Republic of Gilead). But wingnuts do tend to miss details that don't fit their delusional world-view. Now they're claiming that questioners who embarrass their candidates are Democratic plants. And no, there's no equivalence between left and right here.
Ben Carson may be a great doctor, but he's scientifically illiterate.
Progressive Eruptions looks at the "Obama is a Muslim" claims.
North Carolina Republicans loot the cities to benefit their rural power base.
Colorado will make about $125 million in tax revenues from legal marijuana this year (found via Earth-Bound Misfit). The stupid feds still don't get it.
Religious fanatics have published a hit list of bloggers they're threatening to kill.
When you bring two million people into a confined urban space to perform emotionally-charged, poorly-organized rituals, you have to expect this kind of thing. With 769 dead, international tensions are rising.
Worst historical revisionism ever.
To save its economy, China needs reforms more radical than the regime contemplates.
Asshole tourists make life miserable for sea turtles. In Florida at least there's some effort to protect them.
It's just awesome when God kills your baby.
Visit the graveyard of extinct species.
The world could shift entirely to renewable energy by 2050 -- and make a profit on doing so.
If you've ever been to Greece, Italy, or Iran, and haven't yet replied to my travel questions, please click here.
[Image at top found via Progressive Eruptions.]
Time to put down one of the walking dead.
Reading is good for you.
Meet Guillaume de Gentil, the most frustrated scientist in history.
At least 155 people are really into Mary Tyler Moore (NSFW, found via Mendip).
Lowry pwns Trump on Fox, Trump throws tantrum on Twitter, much mockery ensues. But he's still very much in the lead.
Many people find themselves drawn to this lifestyle, but it has its unhealthy side.
Here are ten beautiful bridges -- I find #10 the most beautiful (though they got the name wrong), #8 the most impressive when you consider how long it's stood since it was built.
Witches' Pond in Virginia is shrouded in myth, but has one genuine mystery death to its credit (found via Mendip).
We are the fastest-growing group in the US.
Supporting an anti-bullying campaign is now "anti-Christian hate and oppression", apparently.
A Catholic shrine in France illustrates what a scam religion is.
Here's a bad person and a good one.
Probably best not to resettle any Syrian refugees in this part of South Carolina. It seems to be full of the same religious hatred and potential for conflict that they're fleeing from.
More and more of ISIS's fighters are abandoning the group.
Fox's January stories about Muslim "no go zones" in Britain may finally have gotten it in legal trouble.
Here's a message from 2013 for the anti-Planned-Parenthood nuts.
Sex workers in South Korea march for decriminalization, encouraged by Amnesty International's support.
Christian songs play a growing role in worship -- and they're terrible. But religion's Orwellian use of words (found via Republic of Gilead) is worse.
A teenager in North Carolina is facing felony sex charges for taking nude pictures of himself.
Secular Ethics blog dissects the weirdly-common "what if everyone was gay" argument.
The government-shutdown push was a con game -- against the wingnut base (found via Zandar).
If you're rich and Christian, read this.
Here's more police abuse, this time from Boston. And an ex-cop looks at the James Blake case.
Stop treating the Pope as a liberal hero. He's still evading the one issue any true reformist Pope must address.
Some Tennessee Republicans don't understand the Supreme Court's Constitutional power (found via Republic of Gilead). But wingnuts do tend to miss details that don't fit their delusional world-view. Now they're claiming that questioners who embarrass their candidates are Democratic plants. And no, there's no equivalence between left and right here.
Ben Carson may be a great doctor, but he's scientifically illiterate.
Progressive Eruptions looks at the "Obama is a Muslim" claims.
North Carolina Republicans loot the cities to benefit their rural power base.
Colorado will make about $125 million in tax revenues from legal marijuana this year (found via Earth-Bound Misfit). The stupid feds still don't get it.
Religious fanatics have published a hit list of bloggers they're threatening to kill.
When you bring two million people into a confined urban space to perform emotionally-charged, poorly-organized rituals, you have to expect this kind of thing. With 769 dead, international tensions are rising.
Worst historical revisionism ever.
To save its economy, China needs reforms more radical than the regime contemplates.
Asshole tourists make life miserable for sea turtles. In Florida at least there's some effort to protect them.
It's just awesome when God kills your baby.
Visit the graveyard of extinct species.
The world could shift entirely to renewable energy by 2050 -- and make a profit on doing so.
If you've ever been to Greece, Italy, or Iran, and haven't yet replied to my travel questions, please click here.
[Image at top found via Progressive Eruptions.]
26 September 2015
Replacing Boehner -- a reminder
By now everyone knows John Boehner is resigning as Speaker of the House, effective at the end of next month -- though as to his reasons, one can only guess. There's already a frenzy of speculation about whom the Republican majority will choose as the new Speaker. One Kevin McCarthy, a moderate (by current standards) Republican of the same general ilk as Boehner himself, is said to have the best shot, but the wingnut factions will doubtless hold out for a lunatic from among their own ranks.
Please put down the popcorn for a minute and remember that the Speaker of the House is next in line for the Presidency after the Vice President. If something were to happen to both Obama and Biden at the same time, it's the Speaker who would step into the Oval Office.
And as scary as it is to picture Agent Orange in that position, we could do far worse. Louie Gohmert has been mentioned among the possible candidates. For that matter, there's no actual rule that the Speaker has to be a member of the House, although historically it always has been. In theory they could choose Sarah Palin or Rush Limbaugh or Kim Davis. Anybody. And whoever it is will be two heartbeats away from the most powerful office on the planet.
Boehner's resignation is effective at the end of October. And what's at the end of October? Halloween. Get ready to be spooked out of your wits, for real.
Please put down the popcorn for a minute and remember that the Speaker of the House is next in line for the Presidency after the Vice President. If something were to happen to both Obama and Biden at the same time, it's the Speaker who would step into the Oval Office.
And as scary as it is to picture Agent Orange in that position, we could do far worse. Louie Gohmert has been mentioned among the possible candidates. For that matter, there's no actual rule that the Speaker has to be a member of the House, although historically it always has been. In theory they could choose Sarah Palin or Rush Limbaugh or Kim Davis. Anybody. And whoever it is will be two heartbeats away from the most powerful office on the planet.
Boehner's resignation is effective at the end of October. And what's at the end of October? Halloween. Get ready to be spooked out of your wits, for real.
24 September 2015
Images for the day
A few more pictures with a point.....
From Betty Bowers.
Found via What Would Jack Do.
Created by Tengrain.
From Betty Bowers.
Found via What Would Jack Do.
Created by Tengrain.
23 September 2015
20 September 2015
Link round-up for 20 September 2015
The latest right-wing freak-out is over gay Doritos (found via Mock Paper Scissors).
Fear the wrath of the mortified moggy. Sometimes even a box is too much.
I'd love to try this on Jehovah's Witnesses and the like (found via Mendip).
Helloooo Mr. President blog is back. And for those who didn't know, TomCat of Politics Plus blog has been in hospital for several days in critical condition. Friends are keeping the blog going and posting updates on how he's doing.
Here's a trolling campaign we can all support.
Cats + kittens = cuteness overload.
Ice can be kind of cool.
What if cats really did have nine lives?
Sometimes an asshole pushes you too far (link from commenter Blurber).
Mencken asks after the graves of the dead gods (link from Mendip).
Here's the story of the making of The Wicker Man (link from Marc McKenzie).
Britain commemorates the 75th anniversary of its most important victory in modern times.
Syrian migrants are putting new stresses on the European Union and prompting an unusual effort by Denmark to discourage them.
Iran's President sends Rosh Hashanah greetings.
Western Europe's subjugation and abuse of Greece dates back almost two centuries.
Socialism?
Cities rule! Half of all Americans live in these blue areas.
This guy must be the gold standard of idiots.
Never forget how outrageous Republican behavior has been throughout Obama's time in office.
Atheism makes you fat, apparently.
Yes, teacher-student sexual tension is inevitable, get over it.
Here's a good point about the Ahmed Mohamed clock case (found via Progressive Eruptions).
Solar power is making inroads in Michigan.
Physicist Lawrence Krauss makes the case for militant atheism.
As racism comes out into the open, one of the stupidest novels ever written wins new popularity (see also my review here).
If you doubt how extreme some Christianists are, read this -- even pro-gay opinions are worthy of death (found via Mock Paper Scissors). Then there's Kim Davis's lawyer.
Anti-abortion hysteria is a trap for Republicans.
How does the "war on police" meme spread?
Fair and Unbalanced has a good overview of the real significance of the Dred Scott case.
Huckabee is shockingly ignorant of Constitutional law.
Cynicism is laziness masquerading as insight.
Fiorina's pwning of Trump resonated with many, but she's still a Republican, and a liar. Never fear, Hillary's going after him.
Will Kim Davis be the latest winner of the anti-gay lottery?
The Republican establishment has a plan -- a boring plan. The "Club for Growth" isn't doing much better. And the right-wing "slobs vs. snobs" civil war has reached National Review.
Take it from a blogger who really knows about guns.
We're up to our eyeballs in early-human transitional forms -- and here's another.
It got buried among all the other Republican lies and stupidity, but Santorum told a whopper about Shiite Islam.
August data confirm -- global warming is speeding up.
Fear the wrath of the mortified moggy. Sometimes even a box is too much.
I'd love to try this on Jehovah's Witnesses and the like (found via Mendip).
Helloooo Mr. President blog is back. And for those who didn't know, TomCat of Politics Plus blog has been in hospital for several days in critical condition. Friends are keeping the blog going and posting updates on how he's doing.
Here's a trolling campaign we can all support.
Cats + kittens = cuteness overload.
Ice can be kind of cool.
What if cats really did have nine lives?
Sometimes an asshole pushes you too far (link from commenter Blurber).
Mencken asks after the graves of the dead gods (link from Mendip).
Here's the story of the making of The Wicker Man (link from Marc McKenzie).
Britain commemorates the 75th anniversary of its most important victory in modern times.
Syrian migrants are putting new stresses on the European Union and prompting an unusual effort by Denmark to discourage them.
Iran's President sends Rosh Hashanah greetings.
Western Europe's subjugation and abuse of Greece dates back almost two centuries.
Socialism?
Cities rule! Half of all Americans live in these blue areas.
This guy must be the gold standard of idiots.
Never forget how outrageous Republican behavior has been throughout Obama's time in office.
Atheism makes you fat, apparently.
Yes, teacher-student sexual tension is inevitable, get over it.
Here's a good point about the Ahmed Mohamed clock case (found via Progressive Eruptions).
Solar power is making inroads in Michigan.
Physicist Lawrence Krauss makes the case for militant atheism.
As racism comes out into the open, one of the stupidest novels ever written wins new popularity (see also my review here).
If you doubt how extreme some Christianists are, read this -- even pro-gay opinions are worthy of death (found via Mock Paper Scissors). Then there's Kim Davis's lawyer.
Anti-abortion hysteria is a trap for Republicans.
How does the "war on police" meme spread?
Fair and Unbalanced has a good overview of the real significance of the Dred Scott case.
Huckabee is shockingly ignorant of Constitutional law.
Cynicism is laziness masquerading as insight.
Fiorina's pwning of Trump resonated with many, but she's still a Republican, and a liar. Never fear, Hillary's going after him.
Will Kim Davis be the latest winner of the anti-gay lottery?
The Republican establishment has a plan -- a boring plan. The "Club for Growth" isn't doing much better. And the right-wing "slobs vs. snobs" civil war has reached National Review.
Take it from a blogger who really knows about guns.
We're up to our eyeballs in early-human transitional forms -- and here's another.
It got buried among all the other Republican lies and stupidity, but Santorum told a whopper about Shiite Islam.
August data confirm -- global warming is speeding up.
18 September 2015
Europe's refugee problem in perspective
If you read European news websites at all, you know that for at least a couple of weeks they've been thoroughly fixated on the wave of Syrian refugees entering and crossing Europe (or trying to do so) to escape the civil war in their own country. European popular reactions range from welcoming to threatening, while national governments are going every which way, arguing among themselves about which countries should take how many people, and in some cases (notably Hungary) actively trying to stem the flow.
Rather than throwing around words like "hordes" and "flood" and "siege" as sensationalist websites are prone to do, let's look at some hard numbers. The highest estimate I've seen for the number of Syrian refugees in the European Union is about 350,000. That's a lot. However, the EU is a group of 28 countries, most of them wealthy, with a combined population of 508,000,000. That is to say, the Syrian refugees in the EU are equivalent to substantially less than one-thousandth of its total population.
Jordan, the country immediately south of Syria, has a population of about 8,000,000 and a per-capita income less than one-third of the EU average. Jordan has taken in, by latest estimate, about 1,400,000 Syrian refugees, four times as many as the entire EU, and equivalent to almost one-fifth of its own population.
Lebanon, Syria's western neighbor (and long-suffering victim of the Asad regime's meddling over the years) has about 4,500,000 people and a per-capita income less than half the EU average. Lebanon has received an estimated 1,200,000 Syrian refugees, more than three times as many as the entire EU, equivalent to a quarter of its own population -- though in truth Lebanon had little choice in the matter, given that the hard-to-control Lebanon-Syria border runs close to several major Syrian cities.
Turkey, north of Syria, is a rather different case. With 78,000,000 people and a per-capita income slightly higher than Lebanon's, it's also a military colossus by Middle Eastern standards, and unlike Lebanon could easily have sealed off its border with Syria. Yet Turkey has taken in more than 2,100,000 Syrian refugees, six times as many as the EU.
As if these numbers weren't daunting enough, even more people -- something like seven million -- are "internally displaced" within Syria, meaning they've fled where they normally live due to the war but ended up somewhere else within the same country, and are thus technically not classified as "refugees" even though their situation may well be worse, without benefit of whatever assistance a stable government and international organizations can offer in places like Jordan or Turkey.
Which makes the relatively small contingent of refugees in Europe a sideshow to a sideshow. I don't know why Europe is suffering such tremendous chaos and political upheaval dealing with a problem one-fourth as large as what tiny Jordan is handling with far less fuss, but it's difficult to feel very much sympathy.
Remember, too, that when the bathtub is overflowing, it makes little sense to focus only on mopping the bathroom floor -- what you really need to do is turn off the faucet. The "faucet" driving this flow of human misery is the Syrian civil war, especially the expansion and brutality of ISIS. And most of the burden of fighting ISIS and ultimately restoring peace is being borne by Middle Easterners as well -- primarily the Kurds and Iraqis and various forces in Syria, who are bearing the brunt of fighting ISIS on the ground and making most of the sacrifices involved. In this, they're supported primarily by Iran, though the US and some European countries are also providing important air support (as are Jordan, Iran, and other Middle Eastern states). If the Europeans really want to stop the flow of refugees, or even just the relatively small portion thereof which is reaching Europe, they'd be well advised to ramp up their support for the Kurds and other fighters who are trying to crush ISIS. The problem isn't going to stop until that is accomplished.
In the meantime, maybe we should take pity on the frazzled Europeans and take in their 350,000 Syrians for resettlement in the US. In light of the recent episode of Ahmed Mohamed's clock and some of the reactions from the dregs of our own society, I frankly suspect it would improve the gene pool here.
[Image at top: Syrian refugee children at a clinic in Jordan]
Rather than throwing around words like "hordes" and "flood" and "siege" as sensationalist websites are prone to do, let's look at some hard numbers. The highest estimate I've seen for the number of Syrian refugees in the European Union is about 350,000. That's a lot. However, the EU is a group of 28 countries, most of them wealthy, with a combined population of 508,000,000. That is to say, the Syrian refugees in the EU are equivalent to substantially less than one-thousandth of its total population.
Jordan, the country immediately south of Syria, has a population of about 8,000,000 and a per-capita income less than one-third of the EU average. Jordan has taken in, by latest estimate, about 1,400,000 Syrian refugees, four times as many as the entire EU, and equivalent to almost one-fifth of its own population.
Lebanon, Syria's western neighbor (and long-suffering victim of the Asad regime's meddling over the years) has about 4,500,000 people and a per-capita income less than half the EU average. Lebanon has received an estimated 1,200,000 Syrian refugees, more than three times as many as the entire EU, equivalent to a quarter of its own population -- though in truth Lebanon had little choice in the matter, given that the hard-to-control Lebanon-Syria border runs close to several major Syrian cities.
Turkey, north of Syria, is a rather different case. With 78,000,000 people and a per-capita income slightly higher than Lebanon's, it's also a military colossus by Middle Eastern standards, and unlike Lebanon could easily have sealed off its border with Syria. Yet Turkey has taken in more than 2,100,000 Syrian refugees, six times as many as the EU.
As if these numbers weren't daunting enough, even more people -- something like seven million -- are "internally displaced" within Syria, meaning they've fled where they normally live due to the war but ended up somewhere else within the same country, and are thus technically not classified as "refugees" even though their situation may well be worse, without benefit of whatever assistance a stable government and international organizations can offer in places like Jordan or Turkey.
Which makes the relatively small contingent of refugees in Europe a sideshow to a sideshow. I don't know why Europe is suffering such tremendous chaos and political upheaval dealing with a problem one-fourth as large as what tiny Jordan is handling with far less fuss, but it's difficult to feel very much sympathy.
Remember, too, that when the bathtub is overflowing, it makes little sense to focus only on mopping the bathroom floor -- what you really need to do is turn off the faucet. The "faucet" driving this flow of human misery is the Syrian civil war, especially the expansion and brutality of ISIS. And most of the burden of fighting ISIS and ultimately restoring peace is being borne by Middle Easterners as well -- primarily the Kurds and Iraqis and various forces in Syria, who are bearing the brunt of fighting ISIS on the ground and making most of the sacrifices involved. In this, they're supported primarily by Iran, though the US and some European countries are also providing important air support (as are Jordan, Iran, and other Middle Eastern states). If the Europeans really want to stop the flow of refugees, or even just the relatively small portion thereof which is reaching Europe, they'd be well advised to ramp up their support for the Kurds and other fighters who are trying to crush ISIS. The problem isn't going to stop until that is accomplished.
In the meantime, maybe we should take pity on the frazzled Europeans and take in their 350,000 Syrians for resettlement in the US. In light of the recent episode of Ahmed Mohamed's clock and some of the reactions from the dregs of our own society, I frankly suspect it would improve the gene pool here.
[Image at top: Syrian refugee children at a clinic in Jordan]
15 September 2015
Pleasure, horror, and The Wicker Man
One of my favorite movies is The Wicker Man (1973), a British production starring Edward Woodward and Christopher Lee. The film has achieved some notoriety and most people have at least a vague idea of it, even if they haven't seen it. In case you don't, a summary:
Sergeant Howie (Woodward), a Scottish police officer who also happens to be a devout Christian, travels to a remote island off the Scottish coast to investigate the apparent disappearance of a young girl. He quickly discovers that the locals have some rather unusual habits. They engage in various ancient pagan rituals, and pagan art and symbols are on display everywhere. Sexuality is spoken of, and practiced, in startlingly frank and open ways (heterosexual only, but this film was made 42 years ago). The repressed and priggish Howie finds all this rather offensive and disturbing, but pursues his investigation. Eventually he meets the community leader, Lord Summerisle (Lee), who explains that his grandfather had revived ancient Celtic paganism among the people in connection with introducing new strains of fruit which made the island prosperous.
Howie suspects that the girl whose disappearance he is investigating is being held somewhere to be used as a human sacrifice. As a major pagan ritual event is under way, he infiltrates the site, only to be unmasked. The pagans had tricked him into coming there so that they could.....
.....and then comes one of the most jarring shock endings in film history, as the charming and hedonistic pagans turn murderous. They force Howie into a huge wicker structure in the form of a man (hence the title) and burn him alive. He, not the missing girl, is their human sacrifice.
Not only is this almost too horrific to watch, it achieves a remarkable flipping in the viewer's perception of the characters. The annoyingly prudish and judgmental Howie instantly becomes a figure of profound sympathy, while the carefree pagans, dancing and singing as their atrocity proceeds, look like insane monsters.
The film interests me for several reasons. Until you reach the ending, it evokes, to some extent, the dream of what the modern world might have become if Christianity had never existed (I doubt the ancient Celtic world was quite this sexually liberated -- casual sex gets a bit problematical without reliable contraception). But the ending too has an important lesson, which is connected with the reason why modern pagans and "neo-pagans" don't commit human sacrifices.
I don't know whether ancient Celtic pagans actually sacrificed people by burning them alive (the Carthaginians did, though under circumstances quite different than those depicted here). Ancient pagan northern Europeans certainly did commit human sacrifice, often by stabbing or strangulation, and plenty of corpses have been found in peat bogs which preserved them down to modern times. The Christian fanatics of the Dark Ages routinely burned people alive, not as sacrifices but as punishment for witchcraft, heresy, and the like. And in modern times ISIS used this method to murder captured Jordanian pilot Mu'âdh al-Kassâsbah, and has performed many other horrifying ritualistic killings.
What did all these people -- pagan, Christian, and Muslim -- have in common? They were true believers. They believed, fervently, in the literal truth of the religions they practiced.
In recent decades there's been an increased interest in paganism, with Druidic rituals being practiced at Stonehenge and a temple to the old Norse gods being built in Iceland, while syncretistic "neo-pagan" religions like Wicca and Thelema claim hundreds of thousands of adherents in many countries. But no one seems to think this is dangerous; nobody who visits to observe the rituals at Stonehenge worries that he's going to be strangled and thrown into a peat bog.
The reason is that these modern pagan systems are more a matter of ritual and feeling a connection with ancient tradition (and having fun) than of actual belief. Do modern enthusiasts of Norse paganism, for example, believe in the literal existence of Thor and Odin the same way ISIS believes in the literal existence of Allah? I find that awfully hard to imagine. And that's why they're not dangerous. You don't commit atrocities for the sake of a god that you know is really just a traditional symbol, a projection of human passions, and not a living entity.
The charm of The Wicker Man's islanders is that for most of the movie they look like the same kind of people. This is a place where something vaguely like Wicca or the Stonehenge revelry has become normative and evolved into a whole culture. It's only when you reach the ending that you realize that's not what it is at all -- these people really believe this stuff. And that's what makes the horror possible.
In this scene earlier in the film, the culture clash comes to the surface as Howie confronts Lord Summerisle, who explains how the island got the way it is. The pagan leader's urbane and civilized manner contrasts with Howie's bigoted fury, but towards the end he shows a hint of fervor that adumbrates something dangerous.
One more video (NSFW): In Howie's most-human moment except for the ending, he struggles to resist an almost-irresistible pagan temptation -- writhing in the torment of fighting against his own human nature which he has been taught is sin.
Sergeant Howie (Woodward), a Scottish police officer who also happens to be a devout Christian, travels to a remote island off the Scottish coast to investigate the apparent disappearance of a young girl. He quickly discovers that the locals have some rather unusual habits. They engage in various ancient pagan rituals, and pagan art and symbols are on display everywhere. Sexuality is spoken of, and practiced, in startlingly frank and open ways (heterosexual only, but this film was made 42 years ago). The repressed and priggish Howie finds all this rather offensive and disturbing, but pursues his investigation. Eventually he meets the community leader, Lord Summerisle (Lee), who explains that his grandfather had revived ancient Celtic paganism among the people in connection with introducing new strains of fruit which made the island prosperous.
Howie suspects that the girl whose disappearance he is investigating is being held somewhere to be used as a human sacrifice. As a major pagan ritual event is under way, he infiltrates the site, only to be unmasked. The pagans had tricked him into coming there so that they could.....
.....and then comes one of the most jarring shock endings in film history, as the charming and hedonistic pagans turn murderous. They force Howie into a huge wicker structure in the form of a man (hence the title) and burn him alive. He, not the missing girl, is their human sacrifice.
Not only is this almost too horrific to watch, it achieves a remarkable flipping in the viewer's perception of the characters. The annoyingly prudish and judgmental Howie instantly becomes a figure of profound sympathy, while the carefree pagans, dancing and singing as their atrocity proceeds, look like insane monsters.
The film interests me for several reasons. Until you reach the ending, it evokes, to some extent, the dream of what the modern world might have become if Christianity had never existed (I doubt the ancient Celtic world was quite this sexually liberated -- casual sex gets a bit problematical without reliable contraception). But the ending too has an important lesson, which is connected with the reason why modern pagans and "neo-pagans" don't commit human sacrifices.
I don't know whether ancient Celtic pagans actually sacrificed people by burning them alive (the Carthaginians did, though under circumstances quite different than those depicted here). Ancient pagan northern Europeans certainly did commit human sacrifice, often by stabbing or strangulation, and plenty of corpses have been found in peat bogs which preserved them down to modern times. The Christian fanatics of the Dark Ages routinely burned people alive, not as sacrifices but as punishment for witchcraft, heresy, and the like. And in modern times ISIS used this method to murder captured Jordanian pilot Mu'âdh al-Kassâsbah, and has performed many other horrifying ritualistic killings.
What did all these people -- pagan, Christian, and Muslim -- have in common? They were true believers. They believed, fervently, in the literal truth of the religions they practiced.
In recent decades there's been an increased interest in paganism, with Druidic rituals being practiced at Stonehenge and a temple to the old Norse gods being built in Iceland, while syncretistic "neo-pagan" religions like Wicca and Thelema claim hundreds of thousands of adherents in many countries. But no one seems to think this is dangerous; nobody who visits to observe the rituals at Stonehenge worries that he's going to be strangled and thrown into a peat bog.
The reason is that these modern pagan systems are more a matter of ritual and feeling a connection with ancient tradition (and having fun) than of actual belief. Do modern enthusiasts of Norse paganism, for example, believe in the literal existence of Thor and Odin the same way ISIS believes in the literal existence of Allah? I find that awfully hard to imagine. And that's why they're not dangerous. You don't commit atrocities for the sake of a god that you know is really just a traditional symbol, a projection of human passions, and not a living entity.
The charm of The Wicker Man's islanders is that for most of the movie they look like the same kind of people. This is a place where something vaguely like Wicca or the Stonehenge revelry has become normative and evolved into a whole culture. It's only when you reach the ending that you realize that's not what it is at all -- these people really believe this stuff. And that's what makes the horror possible.
In this scene earlier in the film, the culture clash comes to the surface as Howie confronts Lord Summerisle, who explains how the island got the way it is. The pagan leader's urbane and civilized manner contrasts with Howie's bigoted fury, but towards the end he shows a hint of fervor that adumbrates something dangerous.
One more video (NSFW): In Howie's most-human moment except for the ending, he struggles to resist an almost-irresistible pagan temptation -- writhing in the torment of fighting against his own human nature which he has been taught is sin.
13 September 2015
Link round-up for 13 September 2015
Who the hell decided to put that there?
Pwned! Satan is coming to Arkansas.
What if great literary works were repackaged as trashy paperbacks?
Coolest adult toy evah.
Sleestak lays an old and silly story about NASA to rest.
Alexandra Reeves looks like an artist to watch.
Here's why you shouldn't pour water on a grease fire, and other helpful advice.
This person is, apparently, rather easily fooled.
We are the introverts.
Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch doesn't faze this weatherman.
Here's a dramatic September 11 story which I haven't seen before. And from almost a century ago, a gripping history of German zeppelin warfare against Britain during World War I (found via Mendip).
New discoveries affirm the former power of the now-dead religion that built Stonehenge -- with a lesson for our own time.
The family of two of the Syrian refugees tripped and kicked by Petra László speaks out.
Is Corbyn a mistake for Britain's Labour party? Maybe not.
Republicans are trying to suppress scientific evidence that conflicts with their dogmas.
Pope Francis is about to canonize an architect of cultural genocide (found via Republic of Gilead).
Jessica Valenti makes the case for getting rid of online comments.
If you enjoyed the Labor Day holiday, remember the unions. What astonished me about this story is that 44 million US workers still don't get paid sick leave. What century is this???
Sauce for the poly goose, sauce for the poly gander?
The flower of Kentucky baggotry turned out to support Kim Davis, who is not being hateful! But she can't win, and she's just the opposite of freedom fighters like Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks (found via Republic of Gilead). The lost fight against gay marriage will cost the bigots a bundle.
Surely we have enough trouble with nitwits getting hold of guns without allowing this sort of thing.
Sane(r) Republicans worry that Trump is hardening the party's racist image and may be dangerously authoritarian. At least some conservative voters are turning against him.
Pope schmope -- on the whole, US Catholics are pretty tolerant.
From New York, news of another horrifying police killing.
Green Eagle looks at another mighty display of conservative strength.
An Islamotard stewardess goes all Kim Davis on alcohol sales, but Huckabee, for one, doesn't sympathize.
ISIS is now using mustard gas.
Religious bigotry grows in Russia, and in its Donetsk puppet region.
Is it really your opinion, or are you simply wrong?
We're now 37.9% of new entrants into Harvard, outnumbering Catholics and Protestants combined.
Mock Paper Scissors looks at Jeb's tax plan.
Christians need to realize the US isn't a Bible-based society (found via Progressive Eruptions).
I predict this "sanctuary city" concept is going exactly nowhere.
WTF is going on in Stockton, California? This sounds like barbarian hordes running amok.
A lot of the US is still suffering roasting heat in September, and I think we all know why. Though 2015 is by far the hottest year on record, 2016 will likely be even hotter. At least Obama has out-maneuvered McConnell again, and California is fighting for our survival. Republicans are also hopelessly bungling their opposition to the Iran nuclear deal.
We may now have a 100%-effective AIDS preventative.
A baboon troop in Kenya illustrates how life can change when bullies are eliminated from the group. Can we please arrange something like this for human society?
Pwned! Satan is coming to Arkansas.
What if great literary works were repackaged as trashy paperbacks?
Coolest adult toy evah.
Sleestak lays an old and silly story about NASA to rest.
Alexandra Reeves looks like an artist to watch.
Here's why you shouldn't pour water on a grease fire, and other helpful advice.
This person is, apparently, rather easily fooled.
We are the introverts.
Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch doesn't faze this weatherman.
Here's a dramatic September 11 story which I haven't seen before. And from almost a century ago, a gripping history of German zeppelin warfare against Britain during World War I (found via Mendip).
New discoveries affirm the former power of the now-dead religion that built Stonehenge -- with a lesson for our own time.
The family of two of the Syrian refugees tripped and kicked by Petra László speaks out.
Is Corbyn a mistake for Britain's Labour party? Maybe not.
Republicans are trying to suppress scientific evidence that conflicts with their dogmas.
Pope Francis is about to canonize an architect of cultural genocide (found via Republic of Gilead).
Jessica Valenti makes the case for getting rid of online comments.
If you enjoyed the Labor Day holiday, remember the unions. What astonished me about this story is that 44 million US workers still don't get paid sick leave. What century is this???
Sauce for the poly goose, sauce for the poly gander?
The flower of Kentucky baggotry turned out to support Kim Davis, who is not being hateful! But she can't win, and she's just the opposite of freedom fighters like Martin Luther King and Rosa Parks (found via Republic of Gilead). The lost fight against gay marriage will cost the bigots a bundle.
Surely we have enough trouble with nitwits getting hold of guns without allowing this sort of thing.
Sane(r) Republicans worry that Trump is hardening the party's racist image and may be dangerously authoritarian. At least some conservative voters are turning against him.
Pope schmope -- on the whole, US Catholics are pretty tolerant.
From New York, news of another horrifying police killing.
Green Eagle looks at another mighty display of conservative strength.
An Islamotard stewardess goes all Kim Davis on alcohol sales, but Huckabee, for one, doesn't sympathize.
ISIS is now using mustard gas.
Religious bigotry grows in Russia, and in its Donetsk puppet region.
Is it really your opinion, or are you simply wrong?
We're now 37.9% of new entrants into Harvard, outnumbering Catholics and Protestants combined.
Mock Paper Scissors looks at Jeb's tax plan.
Christians need to realize the US isn't a Bible-based society (found via Progressive Eruptions).
I predict this "sanctuary city" concept is going exactly nowhere.
WTF is going on in Stockton, California? This sounds like barbarian hordes running amok.
A lot of the US is still suffering roasting heat in September, and I think we all know why. Though 2015 is by far the hottest year on record, 2016 will likely be even hotter. At least Obama has out-maneuvered McConnell again, and California is fighting for our survival. Republicans are also hopelessly bungling their opposition to the Iran nuclear deal.
We may now have a 100%-effective AIDS preventative.
A baboon troop in Kenya illustrates how life can change when bullies are eliminated from the group. Can we please arrange something like this for human society?
11 September 2015
09 September 2015
A good neighbor
Here's a side to the Hurricane Katrina disaster ten years ago which every single American ought to know about, although too many don't.
As the ghastly spectacle unfolded -- the flooded city, the floating corpses, the displaced people pouring into Texas, the bungled Bush administration response -- the government of Mexico launched a huge relief operation consisting of Mexican army units delivering and distributing tons of food and supplies to destitute refugees near San Antonio, plus two Mexican navy ships sent to New Orleans to help with the clean-up operation. Even in the richest country on Earth, it can happen that a disaster is so overwhelming that outside help is needed -- and our neighbor to the south, whose border is not far from where the displaced persons had mostly ended up, rose to the occasion.
Yes, that Mexico, the same country Donald Trump has lately been endlessly insulting and threatening in order to whip up the knuckle-draggers of the Republican base.
You can read about it here (found via The Moderate Voice and Fair and Unbalanced), in the words of a senior US diplomat stationed in Mexico City at the time.
This followed on the American assistance offered to Mexico after the great Mexico City earthquake of 1985, twenty years earlier. After the squalid episodes of territorial aggression which marked the early period of US-Mexican relations, such cases of mutual aid in times of need have started to build a better relationship between our country and a rising power of growing importance to our economy.
Unless, of course, we allow the know-nothing followers of a demagogic fool to throw it all away and start a new cold war (and trade war) right within the North American continent.
As the ghastly spectacle unfolded -- the flooded city, the floating corpses, the displaced people pouring into Texas, the bungled Bush administration response -- the government of Mexico launched a huge relief operation consisting of Mexican army units delivering and distributing tons of food and supplies to destitute refugees near San Antonio, plus two Mexican navy ships sent to New Orleans to help with the clean-up operation. Even in the richest country on Earth, it can happen that a disaster is so overwhelming that outside help is needed -- and our neighbor to the south, whose border is not far from where the displaced persons had mostly ended up, rose to the occasion.
Yes, that Mexico, the same country Donald Trump has lately been endlessly insulting and threatening in order to whip up the knuckle-draggers of the Republican base.
You can read about it here (found via The Moderate Voice and Fair and Unbalanced), in the words of a senior US diplomat stationed in Mexico City at the time.
This followed on the American assistance offered to Mexico after the great Mexico City earthquake of 1985, twenty years earlier. After the squalid episodes of territorial aggression which marked the early period of US-Mexican relations, such cases of mutual aid in times of need have started to build a better relationship between our country and a rising power of growing importance to our economy.
Unless, of course, we allow the know-nothing followers of a demagogic fool to throw it all away and start a new cold war (and trade war) right within the North American continent.
06 September 2015
Link round-up for 6 September 2015
If Trump had been willing to discuss the Bible, here's what the results might have looked like.
Freedom! Kangaroos! Pasta!
Someone at this otherwise dull company has a sense of humor. And yes, this will sell like crazy.
The gay agenda -- destroy our neighborhoods with niceness wars.
Best Denali-renaming comment ever!
I bet this holiday is big in Saudi Arabia (found via Mendip).
Ever heard of Australia's Great Emu War of 1932? It really happened!
Green Eagle looks at Europe's refugee crisis, and finds that the story isn't really a European one (see my comment there too).
Less than 400 years ago, England had a religious dictator whose regime was as brutal as ISIS.
Here's something nasty from the Netherlands.
Send the aid to where the refugees are.
Religion's role in fomenting violence can't be waved away with word-games.
New York authorities' absurd attack on Rentboy.com prompts The New Republic to take a stand for decriminalization of sex work. The raid has provoked quite a backlash -- could it be the new Stonewall?
Think I'm exaggerating when I say Republicans are cut off from reality? Check this out. And then there's this guy. And this total nutcase. Oh, and this truckload of horseshit.
The Immoral Minority blog has photos from Obama's Alaska trip (click individual pics for full-size versions).
A Texas doctor pwns the anti-abortion cranks.
Always trust the police, and always believe them.
Make America great again?
Here's what a Jeb Bush Presidency might be like.
Christianity pretty much mandates hypocrisy.
Trump reaches out to the anti-vaccine nuts. Iowa Republicans love him because -- he'd cripple their economy.
Kim Davis is a thug, not a freedom fighter. David E looks at her complex personal life. Republic of Gilead has a history of the case, a collection of Christian Right hysterics in response, and some Twitter reactions from both sides, adding up to more in-depth coverage than you'll find on any conventional news site. Even though she's a Democrat, Davis is a millstone around the neck of Republican efforts to modernize.
These people exist. And this person exists.
Iranian atheist Kaveh Mousavi explains why he wouldn't fake a prayer just to make a religious person happy.
Hummingbird nesting sites illustrate the subtle effects that can guide evolution.
Dutch scientists may have proven "quantum entanglement", one of the more bizarre hypothetical phenomena in physics.
Freedom! Kangaroos! Pasta!
Someone at this otherwise dull company has a sense of humor. And yes, this will sell like crazy.
The gay agenda -- destroy our neighborhoods with niceness wars.
Best Denali-renaming comment ever!
I bet this holiday is big in Saudi Arabia (found via Mendip).
Ever heard of Australia's Great Emu War of 1932? It really happened!
Green Eagle looks at Europe's refugee crisis, and finds that the story isn't really a European one (see my comment there too).
Less than 400 years ago, England had a religious dictator whose regime was as brutal as ISIS.
Here's something nasty from the Netherlands.
Send the aid to where the refugees are.
Religion's role in fomenting violence can't be waved away with word-games.
New York authorities' absurd attack on Rentboy.com prompts The New Republic to take a stand for decriminalization of sex work. The raid has provoked quite a backlash -- could it be the new Stonewall?
Think I'm exaggerating when I say Republicans are cut off from reality? Check this out. And then there's this guy. And this total nutcase. Oh, and this truckload of horseshit.
The Immoral Minority blog has photos from Obama's Alaska trip (click individual pics for full-size versions).
A Texas doctor pwns the anti-abortion cranks.
Always trust the police, and always believe them.
Make America great again?
Here's what a Jeb Bush Presidency might be like.
Christianity pretty much mandates hypocrisy.
Trump reaches out to the anti-vaccine nuts. Iowa Republicans love him because -- he'd cripple their economy.
Kim Davis is a thug, not a freedom fighter. David E looks at her complex personal life. Republic of Gilead has a history of the case, a collection of Christian Right hysterics in response, and some Twitter reactions from both sides, adding up to more in-depth coverage than you'll find on any conventional news site. Even though she's a Democrat, Davis is a millstone around the neck of Republican efforts to modernize.
These people exist. And this person exists.
Iranian atheist Kaveh Mousavi explains why he wouldn't fake a prayer just to make a religious person happy.
Hummingbird nesting sites illustrate the subtle effects that can guide evolution.
Dutch scientists may have proven "quantum entanglement", one of the more bizarre hypothetical phenomena in physics.
04 September 2015
Triumph of the Trump
Republicans are starting to confront the awful reality -- Donald Trump could actually win their party's nomination for the Presidency. Since Trump's rise to frontrunner status in July, many have comforted themselves with reminders of previous election cycles where, this early in the game, some implausible candidate who ultimately flamed out similarly led in the polls. But none of those previous situations really resembled the current one, and none featured a candidate who really resembled Trump. Also, the rise of the WARTs (White Angry Racist Teabaggers*) as the core of the base means that today's Republican party is no longer comparable to its pre-2009 incarnation(s). Trump's lead remains solid across all polls.
Brian Beutler explains why the situation is so unlike 2012, when various wackos surged in the polls but ultimately collapsed, leaving the safe, establishment-backed Romney to win the nomination. This time the WARTs have coalesced behind one candidate while the "moderates" are divided among many. Thanks to Citizens United, weak candidates can stay in the race with the backing of just one or two rich individuals, so the field will not be winnowed quickly and the non-Trump vote will remain divided. Trump's support seems immune to the kind of problems that sank fringe candidates in 2012 -- he's already survived gaffes that would have destroyed an ordinary politician, and he certainly won't run out of money.
Anti-Trumpers are left clutching at straws like Trump's Hugh Hewitt interview, where he stumbled badly on foreign-policy knowledge, but there's no sign that it will make a dent with his followers. How many of them know or care who Qasem Soleimani is? They're already tired of "elitist" assertions that actual knowledge is somehow superior to incoherent fury. They want a leader who can express and embody their tedious rage, and Trump fits the bill.
None of the other candidates can match Trump's charisma, iconoclasm, or chutzpah. He makes them all look small and dull -- fatal to a contender for the Presidency.
Yes, Trump has signed the pledge not to run as a third candidate if he loses the nomination. Supposedly this means he's given up his leverage, and the party leadership can now attack him by fair means or foul, even changing the rules if needed, to deny him the nomination without fear that he'll go rogue and torpedo their nominee. But he hasn't really given up much. How confident can they be that he'll keep his word? The fear of an independent Trump run is still there. By making an empty show of loyalty, he's actually strengthened his position by appearing reasonable. The party will keep treating him with kid gloves while he feels no obligation to reciprocate.
It's not a done deal -- nothing is, at this point -- but we have to be prepared for the possibility that The Donald will actually be the Republican nominee facing Hillary (or Bernie or Joe). That would turn this election into an incredibly high-stakes game. As a know-nothing vulgar populist who has risen to prominence by openly (not in code, as Republicans normally do) whipping up the xenophobia and nativism of the most ignorant and angry element of the population, Trump is an alarmingly Mussolini-like figure, confronting American democracy with a test like that which was faced (and mostly flubbed) by European democracy in the twenties and thirties. While our institutions are far more robust, the vast military power of our country would make such a leader a horrific danger to the world, even if he stayed within Constitutional limits. And there are simply too many unknowns about Trump. We can't roll the dice with the most powerful office on Earth.
Thought 2012 was a nail-biter? Just wait.
[*Term found here. I don't know who originated it.]
01 September 2015
Video of the day -- peace
This video makes a lot of good points, though it ignores what I think is the most important reason why wars between major powers don't happen any more.