Trump caves! Trump backs down! Trump folds!
He had been under plenty of pressure to do so. The dramatic fall in stocks affirmed that the tariff plan was going to be a total disaster. Economists everywhere said the same. Leaders of other countries said so. Billionaire business leaders said so. The fact that the stock market briefly recovered on a false report that the tariffs were on hold said so. Evidently some combination of these got through to him. (Trump has been claiming that lots of countries have gotten in touch wanting to make deals, but there is no evidence for this.)
There was never any chance that the claimed benefit of the tariffs -- bringing industrial production back to the US -- would materialize. Factories take years to plan, build, and make operational. No one was going to make such a large long-term investment on the basis of tariffs that everyone knew would be removed anyway the next time a sane president was in office, and the utter chaos of the US economy and government since the Trump-Musk Dunning-Kruger duo took over makes our country a singularly unappetizing place for investment.
The latter problem is not going away just because Trump has paused the tariffs. As long as he's in charge, especially with Elon Musk also buggering things up, the chaos will continue. There is no plan. Unless Congress gets its act together and reins him in, the economy will be at the mercy of whatever random idiocy the sporadic sputterings of his senescent remaining brain cells happen to generate. He's still doubling down on his bone-headed refusal to understand what tariffs even are, though this must have been explained to him countless times:
This fiasco affirms, yet again, that this country is now being run by a conglomeration of idiots. There is no diabolically-cunning eleventeen-dimensional plan to, say, manipulate the stock market by staging this mess. Trump imposed tariffs on places that are not independent countries or, in at least one case, even inhabited. Even he must know that repeatedly announcing tariffs and then backing down -- for the third time now -- makes him look like a bungler. Musk and his silly DOGE brats keep randomly firing federal workers en masse and then frantically trying to get them back when it turns out they do something critical like nuclear-weapons maintenance (not that what the other workers do isn't important, but it's often important in ways Musk is too stupid to understand). Top cabinet-level nitwits not only discussed sensitive military plans in an un-secure group chat, but accidentally included a journalist who thereby had both the ability and the motive to expose their incompetence. They also keep personal data, which could be used to hack their communications, publicly visible on the internet. And on and on and on. None of this stuff is the behavior of crafty supervillains. The reason why they look like stupid, blundering incompetents is that they actually are stupid, blundering incompetents.
It's not clear why China alone is still being targeted for tariffs. Trump said that it's because China retaliated, but the EU and Canada also retaliated, or at least made it very clear that they intended to do so. Perhaps it's a hopeful sign -- somebody may have managed to get it through Trump's calcified skull that China is actually an enemy, which the EU and Canada are not. As I observed during Trump's first term, if he had worked to get the other major democracies on board with a common campaign of economic pressure against China, it would have been a constructive policy that might really have achieved something. China is the true modern-day Nazi Germany, and any company that does business with that abomination fully deserves whatever nasty consequences it suffers. Trump's error was to start trade wars with everybody, thus unifying the world against the US rather than against China. One can hope that he finally gets this -- although persuading the other big economies to join in such an anti-China campaign would now be much harder, in the wake of the belligerent tariff fiasco.
But the important take-away here is that pressure works. Trump has repeatedly backed down when he faced enough resistance of whatever kind -- now even on the tariffs about which he seemed so bull-headedly determined. He's an airhead, a lightweight, a balloon full of hot gas that can be blown from place to place by whatever winds grow strong enough. We must be the strong wind.
12 Comments:
He sure did take advantage of a little insider trading while he was fucking with the economy.
I suspect that the impending parallel collapse of both the stock and bond markets convinced him that he was about to drive the economies of both the U.S. and the globe into an abyss. It would have been the Trump Depression and, as much as he likes having his name on things, that wasn't one of them.
"He sure did take advantage of a little insider trading while he was fucking with the economy." - Yes, Lady M
His fuckery of the stock market was a trial balloon to teach his cronies what signals they need to pay attention to when he mouth craps another tariff threat. It is all about "Follow the money - who seeks to gain from this shit show." Those oligarchs at his coronation did not invest in him for nothing. "All Hail, SCROTUS! Thank you, Sir, may I have another!" while getting even more stinking rich.
I... abhor... this giant, floating, orange turd - always did. On the upside, he really did rip the bandage off how absolutely corrupt corporations are; more than I could possibly have ever imagined.
Now that he is running, unfettered across the planet... when you think things can't suck any more. It's just... numbing.
I'm with Lady M.
Misfit: That could have had an effect, I suppose. I certainly hope he's sensitive about how (he expects that) history will perceive him. It would be another option for reining him in.
Lady M, Rade, Ricko: I addressed such claims in paragraph 5 of the post.
So... hypothetical question: Do you think >when< SCROTUS is removed from office (bodily, more than likely in a bag), that Vance will continue with the same toxic morons in cabinet positions, or do you think he'll try and get lesser toxic morons in the cabinet so that he can fly more Project 2025 garbage under the RADAR?
I think Vance would be a lot more rational and consistent than Trump -- I don't know enough about him to judge whether he'd be equally evil (he did once compare Trump to Hitler, so his current loyalty is likely feigned for reasons of ambition), but I'm sure he wouldn't be so sloppy and careless. It's very likely that that would involve replacing some of the more hopeless members of the cabinet. Of course more competent cabinet members, pretty much by definition, would be more likely to stand up to him if he violated Constitutional norms.
People are scared and while it's good he backed down for now I can only wonder what crackpot thing he'll come up next to do.
What competent cabinet members ?!
They’re all a disgrace.
I don't think Trump's caving was a surprise; he's always been transactional, so it seemed unlikely to me that he'd stick to the original wacko plan. This whole thing is part of his mania for dominance (claiming all the heads of state were lined up to fawn over him) and retribution (against perceived injustices worldwide because he's so ignorant of trade deficits)--only his buddies in Russia, Belarus, Cuba, and North Korea were excluded).
As the CNN piece observes, it was the sinking bond market that scared him--and it should have. When the rest of the world decides the US isn't worth investing in, we're in a heap of trouble. It's still looking pretty dicey in that area.
I'm amazed that all the so-called smart captains of industry and commerce who thought he'd be a safe bet were so surprised that he acted as he said he would: he's always had a fascination with tariffs based on a total lack of understanding, as you point out. He's a stupid, malignant narcissist surrounded by sycophants who are either as ill-informed as he is or too cowardly to tell him the truth, and we're all now paying for the decisions of those who thought they get lower taxes and deregulation--with absolutely no downside.
Mary: That's the anxiety-provoking part. He's only been in power less than three months and look at the mess he's made. We still have another three-and-three-quarters years of this, unless he has a heart attack from all the junk food.
Anon: If you're referring to my response to Rade, I meant more competent cabinet members that Vance might appoint if he took over as president, not the current ones Trump has. Surely that's obvious.
Annie: I took the liberty of moving your comment here from the China video post, since it seemed obvious this was the post you were responding to.
It's pretty common that men are fixated on being perceived as dominant -- it's a primate thing -- but most are not so childish and obvious and, frankly, pathetic about it as Trump is. It's widely believed that he has narcissistic personality disorder, which can include an insatiable craving for adulation and for displays of submissive behavior from others.
The bizarre thing is that he's not only ignorant but determined to remain ignorant. No doubt capable people have explained to him, many times, the basics of how trade works and how tariffs work. But he just keeps going back to his old misconceptions.
I can't see anyone wanting to invest here when the government is so incompetent and its policies change almost randomly from day to day. And the situation won't improve much when he leaves office. Everyone realizes now that if he got elected twice, someone else equally bad could be elected in the future. The US will now be considered unreliable for decades.
It's bizarre that so many business people supported him based purely on a desire for lower taxes and deregulation and ignored his stupidity, erratic behavior, and other personality flaws. They may have assumed that more sensible people around him would keep him in check, as happened to some extent in his first term. But I think it's broadly true that business executives generally, like Trump and Musk specifically, are just not as smart as most people imagine them to be. The most intelligent people seem to go into law or science nowadays. The captains of industry and the ultra-wealthy mostly achieve their positions by luck or personal connections. During my working life I've seen a few corporate executive types in action up close, and I've never been impressed at all, neither with their intelligence nor with their personal traits. Many of them were bullies and/or foolishly dogmatic people because they've spent so long in positions where they could get away with being like that.
Post a Comment
Please be on-topic and read the comments policy. Spam, trolls, and fight-pickers will be deleted. If you don't have a Blogspot account and aren't sure how to comment, please see here. Fair warning: anything supporting transgender ideology, or negative toward Brexit, or in favor of a military draft or compulsory national service, will be deleted. I am not obligated to provide a platform for views I find morally abhorrent.
On work days there is likely to be a substantial delay in approving comments, since I can't do blog stuff in an office. For this I apologize.
Please be respectful -- no political comments on non-political posts, please.
<< Home