The last phase of the "AI" scam?
All the talk about how "AI" could "wipe out humanity", which the tech billionaire CEOs are suddenly astroturfing, is just the final stage of the scam. By now, even they know that they and the venture capitalists they've been duping are never going to get back all the hundreds of billions of dollars they've sunk into this. "AI" doesn't work. It will never work. It can never work -- not reliably enough to be trusted with anything important, and even the things it can do (crappy fake pictures and wrong answers to questions), users aren't willing to pay for, not at the prices needed to cover the costs. The bubble is going to collapse, meaning a stock market crash that might be as deep as 1929. Rather than admit that they caused this by massively overhyping a fake and unworkable technology, the tech bros are pivoting to claim they had to stop developing it (or be regulated into doing so) because it was too powerful and dangerous. At this point what they're really concerned about is warding off the potential lynch mobs after the entire economy gets laid in ruins by their arrogance and stupidity.
If the war in the Middle East really blows up and causes massive fuel shortages here, that could well trigger the collapse, but it's only the fact that this huge "AI" bubble exists in the first place that will make the results so disastrous across the whole economy.


15 Comments:
This is a tough read in the morning. AI has certainly become an obsession.
Ugh! All I can think about are all the poor people stuck in communities next to these data centers.
Framing AI as "an existential danger to humanity" really is the ultimate tech-bro exit strategy. It sounds a lot more heroic to say you're pausing development to save the human race than to admit you burned hundreds of billions on a glorified autocomplete that nobody wants to pay real money for. When the unit economics crash against reality, the spin machine is going to be dizzying.
Anvil. Too much of an obsession, for some. Time to break the habit.
Bijoux: It's awful, but they will probably shut down after the bubble collapses. And local resistance has stopped many data centers.
Mr Shife: I wonder how many people will be fooled. Certainly the many journalists who went along with the hype won't want to admit they were wrong either.
The pivot from "it'll transform everything" to "it's too dangerous, we must pause" is a genuinely convenient story if the real problem is those return-on-investment numbers just not adding up. The bit about journalists being reluctant to admit they got swept up in the hype is a good point too, that kind of institutional face-saving could drag the reckoning out longer than it should.
It's hardly surprising that the tech CEOs and their toadies have put some thought into how they can weasel their way out of this. Nearly everybody is going to get hurt, and a lot of wealthy and powerful people are going to lose big.
I hope the reckoning is not dragged out much longer. The consensus among economists seems to be that the longer the collapse is delayed, the worse it will be.
There is no nice way for AI to end.
Infidel, as I have mentioned, my background is in cyber security. For the last dozen or so years before I retired, my focus was on cloud computing and the related security. I brought into that a lifetime of coding experience. What I saw promoting the cloud industry set my hair on fire. Up and coming "code jockeys" who could (recklessly) get cloud architecture up and running so that companies could rapidly offload their dedicated (and expensive) data centers to the likes of Microsoft and Amazon. Those "code jockeys" wrote quick slop that got the jobs done, collected a nice bonus and bolted out the door to the next company willing to double their salary, leaving us "old timers" to pick up, rewrite the code and fix all the glaring holes that would have led to security exposures. It was just "rinse and repeat" as some company executive would get a glean in their eyes about how much money they chopped off the bottom line of the books each year with ZERO understanding of what that code would have done to the company had it remained installed as delivered.
Those same "code jockeys" are now AI coders, and the executive mentality has, if anything, gotten worse. Proof is in the shear slop of AI crap that has infested every corner of our lives.
Will it end? That is hard to say. It's not just stopping a data center; it's now escalated to the point of needing to deprogram a public who has accepted the use of AI as part of life. I think it's going to be more of finding acceptable uses for AI and constraining those functions beyond that.
Example; I do not need AI on my Google smart phone. I don't need to dictate Email or texts. Some days, I even forget to turn the bloody thing on. I have removed or shut off all AI functions. I use Linux and desktop apps that are free of AI.
But I go to my doctors office. They use AI to take dictation during visits. I >DO< read the doctor summaries following my visits, and I have not seen and discrepancies between what I witnessed and what the AI wrote. My only concern is... where does that data reside?
Lessons learned from a lifetime in the industry - once you put something out there (on the Internet, in "the cloud", etc.), it's out there for good, and the chain of custody over that data can shift like a grain of sand on a dune.
Anyhow.
R
Since you mentioned Middle East and war, do you think a world war is imminent? Could AI play any worthwhile role in bringing peace between countries? I know tha latter questions sounds silly. Yet!
Rade: I question whether the public is so keen on using "AI", considering how strong the movement against it is becoming, even becoming a major force in national politics. Business is finding that it can't do most of the things they want it to do, like replacing customer service phone people or saving employees time at their jobs.
But the real issue is costs and prices. The costs to the companies that provide "AI" technology are enormous. When they raise their prices high enough to cover those costs, almost nobody wants to pay such prices. They can't go on subsidizing their customers, and thus losing money, forever. When the venture capitalists get tired of shoveling money into a black hole, the whole thing collapses. I'm hoping that all the companies providing "AI" technology will simply go out of business, since it's mathematically impossible for them to ever make a profit, so that the problem will just disappear.
At least in Oregon, the law requires that a doctor's office disclose to the patient that they are using that "AI" transcription, and give the patient a chance to refuse consent. I suspect my ophthalmologist's office has been using "AI" transcription without telling me, because my after-visit summary from my last visit had some very basic errors of fact in it. Next time I'm going to ask them, and be able to cite the law if they aren't familiar with it.
Tomichan: As per my response to your comment on the other post, no, the worst-case scenario in the Middle East is not a world war but a major regional war with world-wide economic effects. And no, garbage technology that can't even get the simplest questions right cannot "play any worthwhile role in" anything at all.
AI might not take over the way some thought but I doubt it's going away anytime soon.
We'll see. It just isn't economical to provide it.
I still know very little about AI. but I do know it's already very unpopular because of the mistakes it makes, the unauthorised cyber hacks, the monstrous data centres and all the rest. And of course it can't do anything creative, it can only scrape what already exists (which of course is plagiarism on a huge scale). Whether the whole AI bubble will eventually collapse, I couldn't say.
Nick: There's a very widespread conviction among economists and tech observers that "AI" is a bubble which will collapse by the end of 2027 at the latest -- and a growing number of them believe the collapse is now very close indeed.
I don’t think AI is going to vanish completely, but it sure doesn’t look like the miracle they sold us. Feels more like another bubble waiting to pop.
We should find out for sure pretty soon.
Post a Comment
Please be on-topic and read the comments policy. Spam, trolls, and fight-pickers will be deleted. If you don't have a Blogspot account and aren't sure how to comment, please see here. Fair warning -- I reject all comments containing any of the following:
1. Support for transgenderism
2. Negativity about Brexit
3. Support for a military draft or compulsory national service
I am not obligated to provide a platform for views I find morally abhorrent. And obviously I'm going to delete anything which is just quoting what an "AI" said. I want to hear from you, not from the always-wrong hallucination machine.
No comments advocating violence against any specific identifiable individual, even jokingly.
Please be considerate -- no political or politics-tinged comments on non-political posts, and no performative cynicism. Finally, please remember that this is a personal blog whose main purpose is to encourage contact from people with similar interests and world-views to mine. I really don't much care for arguing and debating; if arguing and debating is what you want, there are plenty of other places on the internet which welcome that.
From now until the finalization of the election results, no comments claiming the Republicans (or Democrats) will or can "steal" the election. It's pointless to engage with such stuff, and it promotes defeatism, which makes people less likely to vote or otherwise be politically active.
<< Home