A landslide, but no revolution
However, it doesn't offer much hope for real change -- for any progress against the country's fundamental problem of growing concentration of wealth and power in the oligarchy's hands and deepening impoverishment of the masses. Osborn lost by about six points in Nebraska (independents also lost in South Dakota and Montana), and while barely over half the vote has yet been counted on the California billionaire wealth tax, it is currently losing by 56% to 44%. So, as I anticipated on Thursday might happen, even this very large win is just an ordinary alternation of power between the two parties, such as we've been seeing back-and-forth for decades while the parasite class kept getting richer at everyone else's expense. There is no sign here of an economic-populist revolution breaking through the increasing stagnation of our politics in the stranglehold of two parties both dominated by billionaire donors. As I said on Thursday, we'll probably have to wait another two years for the next opportunity to push for real change within the political system, whatever form that might take.
Moving on down my list of the most important issues, the news on abortion rights is mostly positive. Virginia and Nevada passed initiatives protecting the right to abortion in most cases; in both states the vote was almost two to one. Missouri voters rejected an initiative to ban most abortions, 55% to 45%, even though it also included a ban on trans surgeries for minors (which are already banned in Missouri anyway) as a smokescreen. Idaho, however, rejected a repeal of its abortion ban, 56% to 44%.
Tucker-Carlson-endorsed jihadist sympathizer Abdul El-Sayed won election to the Senate in Michigan. The miasma of 1930s Germany which has been hanging over the country since October 2023 just got a little thicker and more poisonous. The continued hysterics about Haley Stevens are astounding. She's being called things like "traitor", as if a politician owed loyalty to a political party rather than to her constituents -- a graphic example of how the very existence of parties corrupts and perverts politics.
Troy Jackson, running on an economic-populist platform (though much less radical than Osborn's), won in Maine. This is definitely a positive, but as a member of one of the two major parties, his freedom of action will be much more constrained than Osborn's would have been.
In Texas, Talarico and Hinojosa both won, by twelve and seven points respectively -- not even close. Most pundits had them winning by a couple of points at best. Democrats also won other major statewide offices and made gains in the state legislature. Hispanic voters' anger over the abuses of ICE probably played a big role, but such large wins in a state that has been solidly red for three decades suggest a fundamental shift. Hinojosa's victory is good news for the anti-data-center resistance, since she made this a major issue.
Trump must take some of the blame here. If he hadn't imposed the godawful Paxton on Texas as a Senate candidate, the race would at least have been closer -- although given the size of Talarico's margin, even Cornyn probably couldn't have won this. The same can't be said for South Carolina, where the grossly unqualified Darline Graham lost by barely four points. If Trump had kept his nose out of it and let the state Republicans nominate a proper candidate, they might have held that seat. I expect the party's fear and deference toward Trump to decrease quite a bit going forward. This is also a defeat for arch-oligarch Elon Musk, who spent hundreds of millions to support Republicans in Texas.
Arizona passed a measure banning men and boys from women and girls' sports. Similar measures are leading in Colorado and Washington, but not enough of the vote is counted yet to be sure of the final result. The same is true of Colorado's initiative banning trans surgery for minors.
I can't find any results yet for Montana's initiative to prohibit corporations from making campaign contributions. David Crowley won handily in Wisconsin, defeating Tom Tiffany, who had supported Trump's effort to overturn the 2020 election. Kansas elected a Democratic senator for the first time since 1932.
Here in Oregon, Tina Kotek was re-elected as governor (sigh). Like Abbott in Texas, she was a big data-center booster until she realized that stance could cost her the election and suddenly changed course. Unlike in Texas, here it apparently worked. I guess Oregonians are more gullible than Texans.
It's important to remember what this win doesn't mean. It doesn't mean that the country as a whole is suddenly OK with identity politics, general woketardia, illegal aliens, or putting male sex criminals in women's prisons. It means the voters are punishing Trump for his abuses of power, his focus on personal vendettas and quarrels instead of the kitchen-table issues that afflict the masses, and his actually making those problems worse with his tariffs and his Iran war which have further inflated prices -- and they are also punishing the Republicans generally for going along with all this. Yesterday voter anger outweighed the toxicity of the Democratic party brand, but that does not erase it.
So there you have it -- a landslide, and definitely a win for the country, but no revolution. The larger-than-expected Democratic majorities in Congress, and the clear mandate they represent, offer a real chance to curb some of Trump's abuses. There is talk of impeaching the embarrassingly godawful Hegseth, and in his case (unlike Trump), it's conceivable that there might be 67 Senate votes to get rid of him. Congress might even be able to pass legislation to do some actual good for the people on fuel and grocery prices, "AI", data centers, and so on -- if handled properly, Trump might be persuaded not to veto such measures, or enough Republicans might be brought on board to override his vetoes. But I see little chance of any serious challenge to the power and wealth of the billionaire parasite class.


13 Comments:
I watched the results up to Midnight, but I could not take NBC any longer. The coverage was fine until about 9PM, and then they carted out Nikki Haley and then had a revolving desk of political pundits to pontificate about the parties instead of giving us data about the elections. I wanted to see how Alaska was going to to, but when I looked at the Alaska SoS site, they indicated that they usually don't call an election until well into the morning.
I am good with the results. I hope the nonsense that has been coming out of the Trump administration will now have some check and balance to it, instead of Magic Mike sending congress home on recess every time something critical comes up.
You covered it well. I probably do not have to read anything else.
I’m happy with the results overall, but you’re right that the apparent fail of Prop 40 puts a turd in the blue wave 🙁
It's important to consider context when evaluating an event. America is still very far from an antisemitic wave; so El-Sayed's election is trivial in that regard. However, it's entirely possible that Trump and his brownshirts may attempt to completely destroy democracy. In that case, it may be possible to recruit enough senate Republicans to attain senate impeachment conviction. One more Democrat could make the difference.
Rade: That coverage sounds weird. I always watch election results on news sites -- since I'm reading everything, I can just focus on what most interests me instead of what some TV station chooses to emphasize.
Anvil: Thank you! That's a high compliment.
Paula: It's a big disappointment. It shows that the billionaires' money, in the form of propaganda, can still deceive millions of people.
Anon: That's what I've been telling myself -- El-Sayed is just one senator out of a hundred, and he won't be able to do too much damage. But it's a step in the wrong direction.
I wish I could agree that the US is "very far from an anti-Semitic wave". The surge of anti-Semitic activity, and threats and violent attacks against Jews and Jewish institutions, since October 2023 (I've provided links to many over the years) show that the ancient evil is very much alive. Some of the activities and tactics of this "pro-Palestinian" movement parallel those of the German Nazi party in its early years, before it came to power. The fact that the left-wing political internet refuses to acknowledge the problem makes it all the more alarming.
I'm sure Trump would like to destroy democracy, but he's proving remarkably ineffectual at it. After all the threats and all the doomsday scenarios all over the internet, this election went off, as far as I can tell, pretty much problem-free.
You gave a great summation.
Thanks for summing it all up for us. You said it all in the second to the last paragraph. This is a clear response to the Trump presidency. However, the El-Sayed win is frightening.
Ricko: Thank you!
Bijoux: Thanks. I do think the reminder is necessary. Voting for a party and its candidates doesn't mean approving that party's whole agenda, it just means deciding that that party is less bad than the other one. The trans nonsense is losing everywhere where it's on the ballot, for example, even in blue states like Colorado and Washington.
If I were Jewish and living in Michigan I'd be very nervous right now. Not so much because of what El-Sayed might do, but because of what his election says about the voters there.
You’re entirely right that this was an indictment of tariffs, inflation, and abuses of power rather than an ideological love letter to the Democratic establishment. Let’s see if this incoming Congress actually has the backbone to tackle Hegseth, data centers, and price gouging—or if the donor leash holds tight once again.
As someone outside the US, I find it hard to keep up with all the races and issues, so I appreciate your summary and perspective on the results.
Mr Shife: I can believe they'll do something about Hegseth. Even some Republicans want him gone. The things that directly challenge the billionaires, I'll believe it when I see it.
Veronica: Thank you. These political struggles are genuinely complicated, but I'm glad if I can provide some clarity.
I often wondered why America voted Trump at all. At least now, quite late, the country seems to have realised its mistake.
Trump promised to address certain very real concerns that many people have, such as illegal immigration and cultural changes being pushed on the country by elites, which establishment politicians refused to acknowledge. Not enough people knew about his track record as a con man and a bully. This election was a reaction to his failure to address the country's real problems in an effective way, and his abuses and corruption, but the issues that led people to vote for him have not gone away, and will not.
Post a Comment
Please be on-topic and read the comments policy. Spam, trolls, and fight-pickers will be deleted. If you don't have a Blogspot account and aren't sure how to comment, please see here. Fair warning -- I reject all comments containing any of the following:
1. Support for transgenderism
2. Negativity about Brexit
3. Support for a military draft or compulsory national service
I am not obligated to provide a platform for views I find morally abhorrent. And obviously I'm going to delete anything which is just quoting what an "AI" said. I want to hear from you, not from the always-wrong hallucination machine.
No comments advocating violence against any specific identifiable individual, even jokingly.
Please be considerate -- no political or politics-tinged comments on non-political posts, and no performative cynicism. Finally, please remember that this is a personal blog whose main purpose is to encourage contact from people with similar interests and world-views to mine. I really don't much care for arguing and debating; if arguing and debating is what you want, there are plenty of other places on the internet which welcome that.
From now until the finalization of the election results, no comments claiming the Republicans (or Democrats) will or can "steal" the election. It's pointless to engage with such stuff, and it promotes defeatism, which makes people less likely to vote or otherwise be politically active.
<< Home