The reason for the season
The concept of December 25 as the birthday of a god originates with the cult of Mithra (depicted above), the ancient Persian god of light and wisdom. Mithra's cult dates back to at least 1450 BC, but became much more widespread after it was absorbed by Zoroastrianism and carried all over the Middle East by the expansion of the Persian Empire under Cyrus the Great in the sixth century BC. Later Mithraism became popular in the Roman Empire, with the god's name being Latinized as "Mithras"; he was also known as Sol Invictus, "the Unconquered Sun". For the first few centuries of Christianity, several different dates around the year were celebrated as Jesus's birthday (the Gospels do not assign a date, though they make it fairly obvious that the birth did not happen in the winter). Eventually Mithra's established birthday was assigned to Jesus in order to Christianize the date and celebrations which were already popular throughout the Roman domain.
The gift-giving and revelry we associate with Christmas come from the pagan Roman festival of Saturnalia, which was celebrated from December 17 through 23. After the triumph of Christianity, these practices became associated with Christmas simply because the two events are close together on the calendar. Another feature of Saturnalia was social role reversal in which, for example, slaves were seated in places of honor at meals, while their masters waited on them. A few traces of this practice survive in Christmas today, such as a British army tradition that officers wait on enlisted men.
Other trappings of modern Christmas, such as Christmas trees, the Yule log, and Santa Claus, were derived much later from Germanic paganism. Santa Claus may even be partly based on the Germanic god Odin, though the basic concept originates with the fourth-century Greek Bishop St Nicholas of Lycia (now in Turkey), and many other strains have been woven into the character.
So we have an ancient Persian holiday with celebrations based on an ancient pagan Roman festival, with some pagan Germanic imagery added on. There's no connection with Christianity except an arbitrary glomming on to the date as Jesus's birthday in late Roman times, which has no basis in the Gospels or in anything else. I see no reason why any secularist would wage a "war" on Christmas, because there is nothing Christian about it.
In modern times, however, something else has been happening. As the early Christians took over "Christmas" from various pagan traditions and repurposed it for their own ends, so today capitalism has taken it over from Christianity and repurposed it as a mass frenzy of consumerism. Very little of the activity surrounding Christmas nowadays even purports to have anything to do with Jesus. The focus is on spending money (or going into debt) to buy things for people who in many cases may not even particularly want them, but it has to be done out of a sense of social obligation. Some of the trappings of the holiday are fun for small children, but for most adults it seems to be dominated by stress and a sense of irksome obligation, exacerbated by the general gloom of the season and the imperative to keep up a façade of cheer and celebration (here are some coping tips for those who need them). And each year the media evaluate all this, not for any religious significance, but for how much the increased spending stimulated the economy. I don't think Jesus -- or Mithra -- would be impressed.


11 Comments:
I love growing old. I have learned to appreciate celebrating the Winter season; enjoying the bounty of the years harvest, the company of good friends and a grand feast. Traditions steeped in reality.
The rest are just smell and bells.
Hell, nothing about American Christianity, especially Evangelical Christianity, has anything to do with the teachings of Jesus Christ.
Nicelyput together.
Hi! I'm as anti-theist as they come, but most of this is wrong. I mean, it's not fact or evidence based.
December 25th was the chosen date because IV century Christians believed in cosmic symmetry, so important figures would live a symmetrical life. From the gospel of John they worked out their Messiah died on March 25th, which meant he was conceived on March 25, which in turn meant he was born on December 25th. It's the calculation hypothesis.
The strongest evidence of the origin of Christmas trees points to 1) medieval Adam and Eve plays, where such trees represented the Tree of Knowledge; or 2) forest regulations in the XVI century in some Rhine cities around this time of year. At any rate, Christmas trees became popular among German Lutherans, and later on Queen Victoria's fascination with the trees helped to make it a widespread tradition.
The "pagan Christmas" story is, funny enough, Christian in origin, as Calvinist puritans thought of most of it's traditions as Catholic, hence pagan, and began spreading this meme. It was further popularized by XIX century German (Christian) theologians from the
School of Religious Studies, who made the connection between Jesus and Mithra and such... but they saw connections everywhere, not backed up by actual evidence or logic.
Anyway, I think a silver lining of Christmas traditions actually having some amount of Christianity in their origins is the fact that the religious part has been so diluted as to make it irrelevant for the most part.
You can exchange gifts with friends, have dinner with relatives and go sightseeing the Christmas lighting of the city without pretending the superstitious piece is true.
There is an annoying atheist anti-anti-theist Historian blogger (yes, that's a thing) that has gathered all this info and the sources in his blog, History for Atheists. I hate to promote his website, but that doesn't mean his arguments in this regard are not strong. He also links to other historian blogs which make similar points.
After all, the main thing here is that we want to get it right, right?
Cheers, and I hope next year is a good one for you.
"Almost nothing about Christmas has anything to do with Jesus or Christianity."
Agree. I think Christians like to feel persecuted, so they blather on about the war on Christmas and how they are bravely fighting against the humanistic tide.
Rade: A lot of people around the world have long felt the same way -- hence why so many cultures have celebrations on or near the winter solstice.
Misfit: True enough, in most cases. Religions themselves also get repurposed to serve the needs of a given culture or subculture.
Anon 1: Thanks.
Anon 2: Sorry, but everything I said here is from the generally-known historical record. I know that Christians at various points in history have tried to retcon Christmas, and the Biblical mythology derived from earlier cultures more generally, to deny its pagan origins, but that's not reality.
Anvil: They do seem to have a deep urge to consider themselves persecuted underdogs. Look at all the fuss they make about people saying "Happy Holidays" instead of "Merry Christmas".
Read a debate in an atheist forum. Apparently some people take exception to atheists celebrating Christmas.
One of the replies was,
Regarding the whole Christ in Christmas thing...
The whole season is about Christ for me.
"Christ, they're doing the music already?"
"Christ, that's a lot of cars. I thought they said millennials killed malls."
"Christ, did everyone forget how to drive in bad weather?"
"Christ, this power bill is high."
"Christ, the neighbor kids got bikes with horns... and a dog."
"Christ, that's a lot of dishes."
"Christ, I'm out of milk and everything's closed."
A good, very good piece.
Thank you, Infidel!
You last paragraph hit the nail on the head.
I LOVED Ami's Comment, ain't that the Truth too!
Ami: Yes, for a supposedly Christian society, there's a lot of taking the lord's name in vain these days.
Burr: Thanks!
Ricko: Thanks. I'd think real Christians must be very depressed at what Christmas has turned into.
Bohemian: Certainly seems that way.
Post a Comment
Please be on-topic and read the comments policy. Spam, trolls, and fight-pickers will be deleted. If you don't have a Blogspot account and aren't sure how to comment, please see here. Fair warning: anything supporting transgender ideology, or negative toward Brexit, or in favor of a military draft or compulsory national service, will be deleted. I am not obligated to provide a platform for views I find morally abhorrent.
No comments advocating violence against any specific identifiable individual, even jokingly.
Please be considerate -- no political or politics-tinged comments on non-political posts, and no performative cynicism (or cynicism in general).
<< Home