10 November 2015

Sixteen centuries

Sixteen centuries ago this year, a great woman was murdered -- and a great civilization, already long moribund and rotted from within, died with her.

We don't know the exact date on which Hypatia of Alexandria was killed, but it was almost certainly during the year 415.  She is generally considered the last major intellectual of the Classical civilization, and some historians use the date of her death to mark the transition from the Classical era to the Dark Ages.

Her life embodied the conflicts raging in the age of decline in which she lived.  Several decades after Christianity was made the official religion of the Roman Empire and non-Christians were subject to increasingly vicious persecution, she remained obstinately pagan.  At a time when dogma and superstition were crushing science and reason, she kept working to advance Greek astronomy and mathematics, even working as a teacher to pass on the treasures of the ancients.  Orestes, the Roman governor of Egypt at the time of her death, had been a student of hers and still sought her advice at times -- a fact which made them both targets of the new religion which taught that a woman should be silent and never occupy a position of authority with respect to a man.

Hypatia lived through the siege and looting of the Serapeum temple (pictured above) by a Christian mob egged on by Bishop Theophilus in 391, an act which may have encompassed the destruction of the last remnants of the Library of Alexandria, though historians are unsure whether any of the Library had actually survived to that date.  In 415 another Christian mob attacked her in the street, dragged her into a church, and hacked her to death with either shells or roof tiles.  She was probably about 65.

Hypatia's life and death were dramatized in a 2009 film starring Rachel Weisz which I strongly recommend; it captures the feel of civilization collapsing into barbarism very well, as well as Hypatia's struggle to preserve the life of the mind in an age of gathering darkness.

About 400 years after Hypatia's death, much of the surviving corpus of Greek writings was rediscovered in the Middle East and translated into Arabic, leading to a huge revival of science and philosophy under the Abbasid dynasty of Baghdad.  The thinkers of this so-called "Islamic" (actually neo-Hellenistic) civilization achieved great things, but faced a constant struggle against religious dogma and hostility to the life of the mind, though this time that hostility took a Muslim rather than Christian form.  As of the twelfth century, the religious purists won out and the Middle East, growing steadily more hostile to science and philosophy, sank into stagnation.

The next revival, again driven largely by Classical inspiration, took place four hundred years after that -- the Renaissance, beginning in Italy and then spreading to the rest of western Europe.  Figures such as Copernicus, Galileo, and later Darwin faced unrelenting hostility and obstruction from the forces of religious fanaticism and intolerance, but they and countless others fought doggedly on, and carried human knowledge and achievement to heights never before reached.

I think we've finally got the bastards beaten.  Yes, the fanatical and the ignorant and the merely unimaginative continue to rail against stem-cell research, life extension, evolution, and on and on, and they've made frightening inroads into one major political party in the most powerful of our countries -- but their hopes of repeating what they did in the fifth-century Roman Empire or the twelfth-century Middle East seem vanishingly remote.  We've come too far now, and our civilization is too widespread.  Any one country that does sink back into ignorance and superstition will merely fall behind and become irrelevant, while progress continues elsewhere.

Hypatia, it took sixteen centuries, but you won in the end.

8 Comments:

Blogger Ahab said...

Fundamentalist Christian zealots didn't like smart, independent women in the 5th century, and they still don't now. Rest in peace, Hypatia.

The struggle between fundamentalist stagnation and reason will always be ongoing, but I'm relieved that reason and progress have gained the upper hand (for now). Let's make sure it stays that way for a long time.

10 November, 2015 05:59  
Blogger Ranch Chimp said...

Good read here, I remember her story ... would have liked to meet her actually. Yeah ... the fundamoralist crap is nauseating and centuries old at that ... all these f'n religious cults (yes, I call them cults, cause that's all the Hell they are) have them sectors still to this day. I'm just glad that I live in the 20th/ 21st centuries ... I would be a dead SOB if I lived in them times without kissing their asses.

10 November, 2015 06:22  
Blogger Infidel753 said...

Ahab: The fight is always continuing. The fact that it was lost at least twice in the past is a warning to us never to let up.

Ranch: If any of us today had to live in those times of decay, it would be absolute hell, and of course any modern-thinking person would quickly get into trouble.

11 November, 2015 04:37  
Blogger Rational Nation USA said...

The forces of decay have raised their heads and the rise is global.

Hopefully your more optimistiç outlook prevails.

11 November, 2015 06:22  
Blogger Infidel753 said...

I'm optimistic, for the reasons I gave and more. Not that we can ever afford to let our guard down.

11 November, 2015 18:42  
Anonymous PsiCop said...

Just saw this as a result of your "obituaries" link, so pardon the years-late comment.

What should anger people (including Christians) even more about the murder of Hypatia is that she wasn't only killed because she was a well-known and outspoken pagan. Yeah, that certainly played into it ... no doubt! ... but it really had a lot more to do with the various machinations of the Church Father Cyril, who'd become patriarch of the see just a couple years before.

I'll keep the story as short as I can, and make the villainy clear.

Two things were going on: First, the city prefect and governor of Egypt, Orestes, had just arrived in his office shortly before Cyril's elevation. He'd been a pagan but tried to triangulate with the Christians, having been baptized by the patriarch of Constantinople prior to his appointment. The city's Christians distrusted him, and he clashed with them over the city's Jews, whom Cyril had ordered exiled (which he wasn't legally able to do, yet did nonetheless). Because Orestes resisted implementing Cyril's order, he was attacked by one of Cyril's monks and nearly killed.

Orestes survived, but was harder for Cyril's stormtroopers — er, monks — to get to. Cyril and his monks fumed, because not only would Orestes not toe their line, and tried to mollify the city's Jews, he also got along well with the pagans, especially Hypatia. His stormtroopers — er, monks — were incensed. Also, some of the city's Christians tried to get the prefect and the patriarch to reach some kind of accord. This didn't work, since Orestes wouldn't tolerate Cyril's bullying and Cyril was too sanctimonious to bend. He decided to give his stormtroopers — er, monks — someone they could attack, who wasn't guarded, and whose death might intimidate Orestes into giving in.

So he told the monks Hypatia was the one who was getting in the way of him and the prefect reaching an agreement. The rest, as you know, is history. They went after her with gusto. Not only did they rip Hypatia to pieces, they used the shells or tiles to scrape the flesh from her bones. Yeah, those stormtroopers — er, monks — could be creative. Ramsay Snow/Bolton could have learned a thing or two from them!

It's not entirely clear what happened with Orestes after that. What is known is that he's no longer mentioned as being in Alexandria. So in all likelihood, he left the city. He might have capitulated to Cyril, or he may have been recalled by the emperor ... but either way, the patriarch virtually ruled Alexandria after that. He went on to have a stellar career as a tyrant for Jesus. He was aided many times along the way by his stormtroopers — er, monks. Later on, he'd even hired mercenaries to go after people (his exploits during the Council of Ephesus in 431 are legendary).

Cyril of Alexandria is such a compelling example of Christian sanctity, that I chose him to be the first in my brief series of blog posts on "Great Christians of History." Would that modern Christians could learn from his example!

03 September, 2018 18:01  
Blogger Infidel753 said...

Evidently religio-politician types (like our modern Evangelical leaders and the Catholic hierarchy) are nothing new. And while Orestes was trying to preserve a pluralistic society, Cyril -- like the Christian Right of today -- couldn't tolerate the existence of any way of life other than his own.

05 September, 2018 04:01  
Anonymous PsiCop said...

No, religio-politicians aren't new! They predate Christianity, as well. There are reasons leaders like the pharaohs of Egypt and Roman emperors were considered gods. Christians just as adapted that playbook for their own ends. And let's not forget the same thing happened in Saudi Arabia, where the monarchs allied with Wahhabist militants there, each to their own advantage.

05 September, 2018 14:15  

Post a Comment

<< Home